Let Them Eat Art: Queens Through the Ages

By Laura C. Mallonee

"Queen of Spades, Part of Playing Card Suite" (1970) by Salvador Dali (All images courtesy of Smith College Museum of Art)  Lithograph printed in color on paper. Gift of Reese Palley and Marilyn Arnold Palley.

In her infamous speech at the British Museum last year, writer Hilary Mantel described Kate Middleton, future queen of England, as a “shop-window mannequin” whose sole purpose was to look pretty and give birth. “A royal lady is a royal vagina,” she declared.

In her infamous speech at the British Museum last year, writer Hilary Mantel described Kate Middleton, future queen of England, as a “shop-window mannequin” whose sole purpose was to look pretty and give birth. “A royal lady is a royal vagina,” she declared.

What exactly we see when we look at a queen is now the subject of BOW DOWN: Queens in Arta historical survey at Smith College. Its prints, drawings, and photographs of women ranging from Marie Antoinette to Queen Victoria suggest that our perception of royal ladies may rely more on how they are depicted than it reflects who they actually are.

But who controls and owns that image? On the museum’s blog, curator Maggie Kurkoski explained that the show’s impetus came from Andy Warhol’s Reigning Queens series, two screenprints of which were donated to the museum by the artist’s foundation. In Warhol’s series, four monarchs — Queen Elizabeth II, Queen Beatrix of the Netherlands, Queen Ntombi Twala of Szaziland, and Queen Margrethe II of Denmark — are fixated in the public eye. Like faces on a postage stamp, they are devoid of personality. As the show’s press release states, “[These women] may reign over the masses, but their image and their person become, paradoxically, public property.”

Most of the queens represented were historically relegated, as Mantel writes of Middleton, to procreational roles. However they actually looked, they were depicted as great beauties — like the aristocrat in Jean-Michel le Jeune Moreau’s 1789 engraving, La Dame du Palais de la Reine, who parades like a regal peacock through a room of admirers.

As for those who were actually powerful, well, they had to walk a trickier line. “When women such as the long-reigning British Queen Victoria and Queen Marie de Medici of France did gain power, they were careful to represent themselves as both royal and maternal, in keeping with the gender norms of their time,” Kuroski writes. In a 1900 photograph of the aging Queen Victoria, for example, the black-clad monarch could easily be the portly, British cousin of Whistler’s mother.

It can be painful — for us and for them — when powerful women don’t live up to our expectations of how they should appear. Hillary Clinton was once criticized for not being motherly enough, and we all remember how matronly Kate Middleton looked in her official oil portraitSunday Times writer Waldemar Januszczak pronounced it “old” and “dour” — a peculiar break from her flirtier paparazzi snapshots, and entirely unbecoming for a “royal vagina.”

Take a look at some images from the show.

 This 1900 photograph of Queen Victoria still in her black mourning gown (her husband died in 1861) was taken by an unknown photographer. The monarch was the first to utilize photography to control her public persona as the “grandmother of Europe.” The museum explains, “In 1853, she and her husband, Prince Albert, began to collect photographs, and they soon realized the power of these life-like images. Queen Victoria released portraits of herself and her family, and the public developed a newfound, more personal connection with their queen.” Eleanor Stanley, lady-in-waiting to Queen Victoria, once exclaimed that “the queen could be bought and sold for a Photograph!”

This 1900 photograph of Queen Victoria still in her black mourning gown (her husband died in 1861) was taken by an unknown photographer. The monarch was the first to utilize photography to control her public persona as the “grandmother of Europe.” The museum explains, “In 1853, she and her husband, Prince Albert, began to collect photographs, and they soon realized the power of these life-like images. Queen Victoria released portraits of herself and her family, and the public developed a newfound, more personal connection with their queen.” Eleanor Stanley, lady-in-waiting to Queen Victoria, once exclaimed that “the queen could be bought and sold for a Photograph!”

Jean-Michel Moreau le Jeune’s 1789 engraving “La Dame du Palais de la Reine” depicts aristocratic life in Marie Antoinette’s hey-dey, when beauty was an important quality for a leading lady to possess.

Jean-Michel Moreau le Jeune’s 1789 engraving “La Dame du Palais de la Reine” depicts aristocratic life in Marie Antoinette’s hey-dey, when beauty was an important quality for a leading lady to possess.

"Her Excellency the Marchioness of Londonderry," an Albumen print by a Lafayette photographer (circa London 1910) (Photo by Petegorsky/Gipe)

“Her Excellency the Marchioness of Londonderry,” an Albumen print by a Lafayette photographer (circa London 1910) (Photo by Petegorsky/Gipe)

CLICK HERE FOR ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s